The Gospel Is Political | The Clearing Gospel — No. 5

The Gospel Is Political | The Clearing Gospel — No. 5
“First, consider the moral predicament of the master who sat in church with his slaves, thus attesting his belief in the immortality of the souls of people whose bodies he owned and used. He thus placed his body, if not his mind, at the very crux of the deepest contradiction of his life. How could he presume to own the body of a man whose soul he considered as worthy of salvation as his own? To keep this question from articulating itself in his thoughts and demanding an answer, he had to perfect an empty space in his mind, a silence, between heavenly concerns and earthly concerns, between body and spirit. If there had ever opened a conscious connection between the two claims, if the two sides of his mind had ever touched, it would have been like building a fire in a house full of gunpowder: somewhere down deep in his mind he always knew of the danger, and his nerves were always alert to.”1 (Wendell Berry)

Nearly a decade ago, sitting in the classroom of a Reformed seminary, I learned one of the most spiritually relevant lessons of my life. It is simply this: to say that the gospel is not political is to utter a falsehood. From Genesis to Revelation, the biblical authors tell a story about power. From Adam and Eve’s desire to be God rather than be created in the image of God in Genesis to the church’s struggle to be faithful under the persecution of the Roman Empire in the book of Revelation, the Bible repeatedly calls the question about power. In stories as sweeping as the deliverance of the Hebrew slaves from Egypt and the Israelites from captivity in Babylon all the way to more minor details such as God’s preference for the younger son, over and over relationships of power are at play. 

To say that the gospel is not political is to utter a falsehood.

With our currently fashionable disdain for politics, that the gospel is, in fact, political, may at first seem to diminish its beauty and force. But the opposite is true. Understanding that the gospel is political returns the words of life to their original, expansive vivacity. Understanding that the gospel is political is the only way to rescue it from those who would make it captive to their self-serving interests, interests which are always rooted in the kind of greed and grasping that the authors of scripture condemn. To say that the gospel is political is not to endorse this or that political party. It is instead to intentionally notice the ideal direction of power that the stories of Israel and the teachings of Jesus illumine. Reading in this way, one quickly discovers that orphans, widows, immigrants, lepers, the disabled, the poor, along with any outsider who is most likely to be left out of the advantages of the system, are of primary concern. Whether the genuine potential to flourish—to have space to become, to have time to grow—is flowing toward such people is the test of the gospel because power is among its central concerns. Wherever religion initiates, maintains, or entrenches the marginalization of the least, that religion is idolatry and not aligned with the faith of Jesus.

My professor could stand before me and condemn the role of the Black church in the Civil Rights movement not because of anything found in the Bible. It is true that the throne of God has been remade into the cross of Jesus and therefore everything we think about the meaning and purpose of faith has been transformed. Yet, the cross does not condone passivity concerning the arrangement of power but, instead, leads us to sharpen our focus on who Jesus reveals God to be. And the mission of Jesus is precisely about liberation. Good news to the poor. Freedom to the oppressed. These are the measures by which we know the gospel.

The mission of Jesus is precisely about liberation. Good news to the poor. Freedom to the oppressed. These are the measures by which we know the gospel.

Still, my professor could say these things because he was compelled to, just as his ancestors had been compelled to. Compelled not because of the Spirit or even any sense of logic. Compelled because of a need for a veneer of coherence even if that coherence was grounded in a falsehood. In order to tolerate the buying and selling of human beings, in order to justify the removal and attempted eradication of indigenous people, in order to legislate inequity for those on the margins while continuing to think of oneself as a Christian, one had to make the gospel only about the world of the hereafter rather than the here and now. One had to contort the faith of Jesus and the stories of scripture into a testament which was concerned narrowly with what one believes rather than what one does, with the private morality which advantages the few instead of the social ethics and communal care which advantage the many. The insidious lie that the gospel is not political—that it does not insist on the flow of power to the margins—is the cover that allows the current arrangements of power to go unquestioned. To say that the gospel is not political is to utter a slogan which upholds and strengthens supremacist ways of relating to those Jesus calls our neighbors. 

Wherever religion initiates, maintains, or entrenches the marginalization of the least, that religion is idolatry and not aligned with the faith of Jesus.

When I decided to take a class at a Reformed seminary, it had been for the sake of my own self-understanding and search for wholeness. What I discovered was the shimmering veil of false coherence. For those of us journeying toward good news for becoming free, weaving stories about power back into the fabric of our faith is essential work. The warp and weft of the faith of Jesus involves politics because it involves justice. What is needed now are workers at the loom, pulling the threads together with care in a way that disrupts the veneer of coherence which passes as Christianity in this country and reveals the more vivid vision that has always been good news to the poor and the oppressed.


1  The Hidden Wound by Wendell Berry